Fidelity & Constraint: How the Supreme Court Has Read the American Constitution
- ISBN-10
- 0190932562
- ISBN-13
- 9780190932565
- Category
- Law
- Pages
- 448
- Language
- English
- Published
- 2019-04-03
- Publisher
- Oxford University Press
- Author
- Lawrence Lessig
Description
The fundamental fact about our Constitution is that it is old -- the oldest written constitution in the world. The fundamental challenge for interpreters of the Constitution is how to read that old document over time. In Fidelity & Constraint, legal scholar Lawrence Lessig explains that one of the most basic approaches to interpreting the constitution is the process of translation. Indeed, some of the most significant shifts in constitutional doctrine are products of the evolution of the translation process over time. In every new era, judges understand their translations as instances of "interpretive fidelity," framed within each new temporal context. Yet, as Lessig also argues, there is a repeatedly occurring countermove that upends the process of translation. Throughout American history, there has been a second fidelity in addition to interpretive fidelity: what Lessig calls "fidelity to role." In each of the cycles of translation that he describes, the role of the judge -- the ultimate translator -- has evolved too. Old ways of interpreting the text now become illegitimate because they do not match up with the judge's perceived role. And when that conflict occurs, the practice of judges within our tradition has been to follow the guidance of a fidelity to role. Ultimately, Lessig not only shows us how important the concept of translation is to constitutional interpretation, but also exposes the institutional limits on this practice. The first work of both constitutional and foundational theory by one of America's leading legal minds, Fidelity & Constraint maps strategies that both help judges understand the fundamental conflict at the heart of interpretation whenever it arises and work around the limits it inevitably creates.
Get the book
Other editions
-
- 2019-04-03
- 448 pages
- Ebook
- Oxford University Press
-
- 2019
- 600 pages
- Paperback
- Oxford University Press, USA
Similar books
-
America, Compromised
By Lawrence LessigIf we don’t acknowledge our own part in that, and act now to change it, we will hand our children a less perfect union than we were given. It will be a long struggle. This book represents the first steps.
-
Source Coding Theory
By Robert M. GraySource coding theory has as its goal the characterization of the optimal performance achievable in idealized communication systems which must code an information source for transmission over a digital communication or storage channel for ...
-
Constitutional Originalism: A Debate
By Robert W. Bennett, Lawrence B. SolumRobert H. Bork, “Neutral Principles and Some First Amendment Problems,” Indiana Law Journal 47 (1971): 13. 200. Bork, The Tempting of America, 82. 201. See generally Bennett, “'Mere' Rationality.” 202. Bork, “Neutral Principles,” 76, ...
-
Interpretable Machine Learning
By Christoph MolnarThis book is about making machine learning models and their decisions interpretable.
-
Code (Volume 4 of 4) (EasyRead Super Large 24pt Edition)
Code (Volume 4 of 4) (EasyRead Super Large 24pt Edition)
-
The Second Creation: Fixing the American Constitution in the Founding Era
By Jonathan GienappOn Madison and public opinion, above all see Colleen A. Sheehan, James Madison and the Spirit of Republican Government (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2009), chs. 3–5; Robert W. T. Martin, Government by Dissent: Protest, ...
-
They Don't Represent Us: Reclaiming Our Democracy
By Lawrence LessigIn They Don’t Represent Us, Harvard law professor Lawrence Lessig charts the way in which the fundamental institutions of our democracy, including our media, respond to narrow interests rather than to the needs and wishes of the ...
-
Visualising Business Transformation: Pictures, Diagrams and the Pursuit of Shared Meaning
By Jonathan Whelan, Stephen WhitlaThis is surprising, because although they can look very different, and tend to be produced by distinct groups of people, they are all modelling different aspects of the same thing.
-
The Living Constitution
By David A. StraussStrauss explores how judicial decisions adapted the Constitution's text (and contradicted original intent) to produce some of our most profound accomplishments: the end of racial segregation, the expansion of women's rights, and the freedom ...
-
Being and Event
By Alain BadiouA translation of one of the single most important works of recent French philosophy, Badiou's magnum opus, and a must-have for his growing following and anyone interested in contemporary Continental thought.