Free Speech and the Politics of Identity

ISBN-10: 0198298862
ISBN-13: 9780198298861
Category: Language Arts & Disciplines
Pages: 278
Language: English
Published: 1999
Publisher: Oxford University Press, USA
Author: David A. J. Richards

Description

Free Speech and the Politics of Identity challenges the scholarly view as well as the dominant legal view outside the United States that the right of free speech may reasonably be traded off in pursuit of justice to stigmatized minorities. These views appeal to an alleged reasonable balancebetween two basic human rights: the right of free speech and the right against unjust discrimination. Compelling arguments of normative political theory and interpretative history show, however, that these rights are structurally linked: the abridgement of one compromises the other. To make thiscase, David Richards offers an original political theory of toleration and of structural injustice that addresses the nature and scope of the right of free speech and the right against unjust discrimination; its analytic focus is on the role played by members of subordinated groups in the protest ofthe terms of structural injustice (the politics of identity), advancing constitutional justice under law. While the argument is developed on the basis of American constitutional experience from the antebellum period forward, its normative force is brought to bear both in defending and criticizingsome aspects of American law and in challenging the continuing legitimacy of laws against group libel, obscenity, and blasphemy under national legal systems (including Germany, France, Britain, Canada, Israel, India, South Africa, and others), regional systems (the jurisprudence of the EuropeanCourt of Human Rights), and public international law. The book's innovative normative and interpretative methodology calls for a new departure in comparative public law, in which all states responsibly address their common problems not only of inadequate protection of free speech but correlativefailure to take seriously the continuing political power of such evils as anti-Semitism, racism, sexism, and homophobia.

Get the book

Similar books

A Republican Theory of Free Speech: Critical Civility
By Suzanne Whitten
This book offers the first comprehensive philosophical examination of the free speech ‘battles’ of the last decade, arguing for a critical republican conception of civility as an explanatory and prescriptive solution.
The Madness of Crowds: Gender, Race and Identity
By Douglas Murray
One of the few writers who dares to counter the prevailing view and question the dramatic changes in our society – from gender reassignment for children to the impact of transgender rights on women – Murray's penetrating book, now ...
Radical Identity Politics: Beyond Right and Left
By Torben Bech Dyrberg
This book outlines significant traits of radical leftist identity politics.
We Need New Stories: The Myths that Subvert Freedom
By Nesrine Malik
" In We Need New Stories, Nesrine Malik explains that all of these arguments are political myths—variations on the lie that American values are under assault.
Free Speech on Campus
By Sigal R. Ben-Porath
In Free Speech on Campus, political philosopher Sigal Ben-Porath examines the current state of the arguments, using real-world examples to explore the contexts in which conflicts erupt, as well as to assess the place of identity politics ...
I'll Burn That Bridge When I Get to It: Heretical Thoughts on Identity Politics, Cancel Culture and Academic Freedom
By Norman Finkelstein
Originating as a response to the 2020 publication of "A Letter on Justice and Open Debate" in Harper's, Finkelstein's new book I'll Burn That Bridge When I Get to It takes aim at both "cancel culture" and "identity politics".
The Right’s First Amendment: The Politics of Free Speech & the Return of Conservative Libertarianism
By Wayne Batchis
What do these changes mean for the future of First Amendment interpretation? Wayne Batchis offers a fresh entry point into these issues by grounding his study in both political and legal scholarship.
Religion, Politics, and American Identity: New Directions, New Controversies
By Andrew R. Murphy, David S. Gutterman
This volume brings together an impressive group of scholars to build on past work and broaden the scope of this crucial inquiry in two respects: by exploring aspects of the religion-politics nexus in the United States that have been ...
Fractured: Race, Class, Gender and the Hatred of Identity Politics
By MICHAEL. CHARNLEY RICHMOND, Alex Charnley
It has armed the march of the transphobes. In Fractured, the authors move away from the identity politics debate.
The Case for Color-Blind Equality in an Age of Identity Politics
By Alan Dershowitz
... Impeaching Trump The Case Against BDS: Why Singling Out Israel for Boycott Is AntiSemitic and Anti-Peace Trumped Up: How Criminalization of Political Differences Endangers Democracy Electile Dysfunction: A Guide for Unaroused Voters ...