Tocqueville's Nightmare: The Administrative State Emerges in America, 1900-1940
- ISBN-10
- 0199920877
- ISBN-13
- 9780199920877
- Category
- Law
- Pages
- 272
- Language
- English
- Published
- 2014-04-21
- Publisher
- Oxford University Press
- Author
- Daniel R. Ernst
Description
In the 1830s, the French aristocrat Alexis de Tocqueville warned that "insufferable despotism" would prevail if America ever acquired a national administrative state. Today's Tea Partiers evidently believe that, after a great wrong turn in the early twentieth century, Tocqueville's nightmare has come true. In those years, it seems, a group of radicals, seduced by alien ideologies, created vast bureaucracies that continue to trample on individual freedom. In Tocqueville's Nightmare, Daniel R. Ernst destroys this ahistorical and simplistic narrative. He shows that, in fact, the nation's best corporate lawyers were among the creators of "commission government" that supporters were more interested in purging government of corruption than creating a socialist utopia, and that the principles of individual rights, limited government, and due process were built into the administrative state. Far from following "un-American" models, American state-builders rejected the leading European scheme for constraining government, the Rechtsstaat (a state of rules). Instead, they looked to an Anglo-American tradition that equated the rule of law with the rule of courts and counted on judges to review the bases for administrators' decisions. Soon, however, even judges realized that strict judicial review shifted to courts decisions best left to experts. The most masterful judges, including Charles Evans Hughes, Chief Justice of the United States from 1930 to 1941, ultimately decided that a "day in court" was unnecessary if individuals had already had a "day in commission" where the fundamentals of due process and fair play prevailed. This procedural notion of the rule of law not only solved the judges' puzzle of reconciling bureaucracy and freedom. It also assured lawyers that their expertise in the ways of the courts would remain valuable, and professional politicians that presidents would not use administratively distributed largess as an independent source of political power. Tocqueville's nightmare has not come to pass. Instead, the American administrative state is a restrained and elegant solution to a thorny problem, and it remains in place to this day.
Get the book
Other editions
-
- 2014
- 226 pages
- Paperback
- OUP Us
Similar books
-
Judicializing the Administrative State: The Rise of the Independent Regulatory Commissions in the United States, 1883-1937
By Hiroshi OkayamaOkayama demonstrates that the American institutional combination of common law and the presidential system favored policy implementation through formal procedures by autonomous agencies and that it induced the creation and development of ...
-
Harvard Law Review: Volume 129, Number 3 - January 2016
By Harvard Law ReviewIt comes out monthly from November through June and has roughly 2500 pages per volume. Student editors make all editorial and organizational decisions. This is the third issue of academic year 2015-2016.
-
Demos Assembled: Democracy and the International Origins of the Modern State, 1840–1880
By Stephen W. SawyerLucien Jaume has specifically noted this point in his intellectual biography of Tocqueville, insisting that “we will ... Daniel Ernst's book, Tocqueville's Nightmare, suggests like so many others that Tocqueville's observations in ...
-
Law in American History, Volume III: 1930-2000
By G. Edward WhiteThe letter is quoted in Ernst, Tocqueville's Nightmare, 58. 55. See George K. Ray and Harvey Wienke, “Hot Oil on the Unchartered Seas of Delegated Powers,” 29 Ill. L. Rev. 1035 (1935), and several letters exchanged among staff members ...
-
Tocqueville on American Character: Why Tocqueville's Brilliant Exploration of the American Spirit is as Vital and Important Today as It...
By Michael A. LedeenHis celebrated Democracy in America, the most quoted work on America ever written, presented the new Americans with a degree of understanding no one had accomplished before or has since.
-
Bureaucracy in America: The Administrative State’s Challenge to Constitutional Government
By Joseph PostellThis book examines the history of administrative power in America and argues that modern administrative law has failed to protect the principles of American constitutionalism as effectively as earlier approaches to regulation and ...
-
Rights Delayed: The American State and the Defeat of Progressive Unions, 1935-1950
By Charles W. RomneyFor example F. R. Donahue dictated several letters in October 1945 about “labor disputes which have occurred in the shook mills in the States of California, Oregon, and Washington.” Donahue also dictated letters in July 1945 about a ...
-
Jews and the Law
By Marc Galanter, Ari Mermelstein, Victoria Saker WoesteJustice: Terrorism Cases, Enemy Combatants, and Political Justicein U.S. Courts,” Politics &Society 33 (2005): 637–69;Anne Gearan, “Bush's War onTerror Runs Afoul of theRuleof Law: Despite Popular Support, ItHasSuffered Mostly Defeat in ...
-
Creating the Administrative Constitution: The Lost One Hundred Years of American Administrative Law
By Jerry L. MashawOn the difficulties of this period, see PHILLIPS, supra note 39, at 33—45. 54. A few state banks were used in the East as well. See Banks in Which the Receipts from the Public Lands Are Deposited (Feb. 14, 1822), reprinted in 3 AMERICAN ...
-
The Attack of the Blob: Hannah Arendt's Concept of the Social
By Hanna Fenichel PitkinArendt and Tocqueville This was Arendt's conclusion , too , as the immediate danger of McCarthyism receded . ... Most striking are the similarities between Tocqueville's nightmare vision of the tutelary power that is “ society itself ...