Electing Judges: The Surprising Effects of Campaigning on Judicial Legitimacy
- ISBN-10
- 0226291103
- ISBN-13
- 9780226291109
- Category
- Political Science
- Pages
- 226
- Language
- English
- Published
- 2012-09-20
- Publisher
- University of Chicago Press
- Author
- James L. Gibson
Description
A revealing and provocative study of the effects of judicial elections on state courts and public perceptions of impartiality. In Electing Judges, leading judicial politics scholar James L. Gibson responds to the growing concern that the realities of campaigning are undermining judicial independence and even the rule of law. Armed with empirical evidence, Gibson offers the most systematic and comprehensive study to date of the impact of judicial elections on public perceptions of fairness, impartiality, and the legitimacy of state courts—and his findings are both counterintuitive and controversial. Gibson finds that ordinary Americans do not conclude from campaign promises that judges are incapable of making impartial decisions. Instead, he shows, they understand the process of deciding cases to be an exercise in policy making, rather than of simply applying laws to individual cases—and consequently think it’s important for candidates to reveal where they stand on important issues. Negative advertising also turns out to have a limited effect on perceptions of judicial legitimacy, though certain kinds of campaign contributions can create the appearance of improper bias. Taking both the good and bad into consideration, Gibson argues persuasively that elections are ultimately beneficial in boosting the institutional legitimacy of courts, despite the slight negative effects of some campaign activities
Get the book
Other editions
-
- 2012-09-20
- 226 pages
- Paperback
- University of Chicago Press
Similar books
-
Running for Judge: The Rising Political, Financial, and Legal Stakes of Judicial Elections
By Matthew J. Streb"This outstanding collection of essays provides new insight into one of the most important features of the American judicial system.
-
In Defense of Judicial Elections
By Chris W. Bonneau, Melinda Gann HallThis provocative book is essential reading for anyone interested in the politics of judicial selection, law and politics, or the electoral process.
-
The Selection and Tenure of Judges
By Evan HaynesHaynes, Evan. The Selection and Tenure of Judges. [Newark]: The National Conference of Judicial Councils, 1944. xix, 308 pp. Reprint available January, 2005 by the Lawbook Exchange, Ltd. ISBN 1-58477-483-5.
-
Who is to Judge?: The Perennial Debate Over Whether to Elect or Appoint America's Judges
By Charles Gardner GeyhIn Who Is to Judge?, judicial politics expert Charles Gardner Geyh exposes and explains the overstatements of both sides in the judicial selection debate.
-
Judicial Elections in the 21st Century
By Chris W. Bonneau, Melinda Gann HallOverall, this collection provides a sharp evidence-based portrait of how modern judicial elections actually work in practice and their consequences for state judiciaries and the American people.
-
Running for Judge: The Rising Political, Financial, and Legal Stakes of Judicial Elections
By Matthew J StrebThe book ties together the current state of the judicial elections literature, and presents new evidence on a wide range of important topics, including: the history of judicial elections; an understanding of the types of judicial elections; ...
-
Two-Fer: Electing a President and a Supreme Court
By Clint BolickThis is why, Two-Fer shows, it is important to carefully consider who will possess the awesome power to nominate and confirm judges.
-
Contemplating Courts
By Lee EpsteinThe book's five parts cover subjects taught in most judicial politics courses. Because each chapter stands alone, instructors have the flexibility of assigning less than the whole book or chapters in a different order.
-
Electing Justice: The Law and Ethics of Judicial Election Campaigns
By Patrick M. McFaddenElecting Justice: The Law and Ethics of Judicial Election Campaigns
-
The Role Of The Supreme Court In American Politics: The Least Dangerous Branch
By Richard PacelleWhile the Framers of the Constitution felt that the judiciary would be the "least dangerous branch" of government, many have come to the conclusion that courts govern America, a notion at odds with democratic government.Richard Pacelle ...