Conflicts of Conscience in Health Care: An Institutional Compromise
- ISBN-10
- 0262263637
- ISBN-13
- 9780262263634
- Category
- Science
- Pages
- 368
- Language
- English
- Published
- 2010-08-13
- Publisher
- MIT Press
- Author
- Holly Fernandez Lynch
Description
A balanced proposal that protects both a patient's access to care and a physician's ability to refuse to provide certain services for reasons of conscience. Physicians in the United States who refuse to perform a variety of legally permissible medical services because of their own moral objections are often protected by “conscience clauses.” These laws, on the books in nearly every state since the legalization of abortion by Roe v. Wade, shield physicians and other health professionals from such potential consequences of refusal as liability and dismissal. While some praise conscience clauses as protecting important freedoms, opponents, concerned with patient access to care, argue that professional refusals should be tolerated only when they are based on valid medical grounds. In Conflicts of Conscience in Health Care, Holly Fernandez Lynch finds a way around the polarizing rhetoric associated with this issue by proposing a compromise that protects both a patient's access to care and a physician's ability to refuse. This focus on compromise is crucial, as new uses of medical technology expand the controversy beyond abortion and contraception to reach an increasing number of doctors and patients. Lynch argues that doctor-patient matching on the basis of personal moral values would eliminate, or at least minimize, many conflicts of conscience, and suggests that state licensing boards facilitate this goal. Licensing boards would be responsible for balancing the interests of doctors and patients by ensuring a sufficient number of willing physicians such that no physician's refusal leaves a patient entirely without access to desired medical services. This proposed solution, Lynch argues, accommodates patients' freedoms while leaving important room in the profession for individuals who find some of the capabilities of medical technology to be ethically objectionable.
Get the book
Other editions
-
- 2010-08
- 368 pages
- Paperback
- MIT Press
-
- 2008
- 345 pages
- Paperback
- MIT Press
Similar books
-
Conscientious Objection in Health Care: An Ethical Analysis
By Mark R. Wicclair... Rosamund 52–3, 72, 74 rights-based ethical theories 46 rights-protection model 64–5, 66, 68, 229 Roe v Wade 15, ... Thomas 161 Singer, Marcus 223 smallpox vaccination 14 social conservatives 222 social contract 71 and obligations of ...
-
Conscience in Reproductive Health Care: Prioritizing Patient Interests
By Carolyn McLeodIn Conscience in Reproductive Health Care, Carolyn McLeod responds to a growing worldwide trend of health care professionals conscientiously refusing to provide abortions and similar reproductive health services in countries where these ...
-
Law, Religion, and Health in the United States
By I. Glenn Cohen, Holly Fernandez Lynch, Elizabeth SepperThis book explores the critical role of law in protecting - and protecting against - religious beliefs in American health care.
-
Moral Resilience: Transforming Moral Suffering in Healthcare
By Cynda Hylton RushtonSuffering is an unavoidable reality in health care. Not only are patients and families suffering but also the clinicians who care for them.
-
Conflict of Interest in Medical Research, Education, and Practice
By Institute of Medicine, Board on Health Sciences Policy, EducationThe book will serve as an invaluable resource for individuals and organizations committed to high ethical standards in all realms of medicine.
-
Manual of Catholic Medical Ethics: Responsible Healthcare from a Catholic Perspective
By Willem Jacobus Eijk, L. J. M. Hendriks, J. Anthony RaymakersTaking into account the most recent developments many actual questions are discussed. They are presented according to the phases of life where medical-ethical questions may arise.
-
The Conscience Wars: Rethinking the Balance Between Religion, Identity, and Equality
By Susanna Mancini, Michel RosenfeldExplores the multifaceted debate on the interconnection between conscientious objections, religious liberty, and the equality of women and sexual minorities.
-
Transparency in Health and Health Care in the United States: Law and Ethics
By I. Glenn Cohen, Holly Fernandez Lynch, Carmel ShacharExamines the impact of increased transparency on the legal, medical, and business structures of the American health care system.
-
Case Studies in Pharmacy Ethics
By Amy Haddad, Robert VeatchThe second edition accounts for the many changes in pharmacy since 1999, including assisted suicide in Oregon, the purchasing of less expensive drugs from Canada, and the influence of managed care on prescriptions.
-
Managing Conflict of Interest in the Public Sector A Toolkit: A Toolkit
By OECDThis Toolkit provides non-technical, practical help to enable officials to recognise conflict of interest situations and help them to ensure that integrity and reputation are not compromised.