The Limits of Legitimacy: Dissenting Opinions, Media Coverage, and Public Responses to Supreme Court Decisions

The Limits of Legitimacy: Dissenting Opinions, Media Coverage, and Public Responses to Supreme Court Decisions
ISBN-10
0472052748
ISBN-13
9780472052745
Category
Political Science
Pages
243
Language
English
Published
2015-09-22
Publisher
University of Michigan Press
Author
Michael Zilis

Description

When the U.S. Supreme Court announces a decision, reporters simplify and dramatize the complex legal issues by highlighting dissenting opinions and thus emphasizing conflict among the justices themselves. This often sensationalistic coverage fosters public controversy over specific rulings despite polls which show that Americans strongly believe in the Court’s legitimacy as an institution. In The Limits of Legitimacy, Michael A. Zilis illuminates this link between case law and public opinion. Drawing on a diverse array of sources and methods, he employs case studies of eminent domain decisions, analysis of media reporting, an experiment to test how volunteers respond to media messages, and finally the natural experiment of the controversy over the Affordable Care Act, popularly known as Obamacare. Zilis finds that the media tends not to quote from majority opinions. However, the greater the division over a particular ruling among the justices themselves, the greater the likelihood that the media will criticize that ruling, characterize it as "activist," and employ inflammatory rhetoric. Hethen demonstrates that the media’s portrayal of a decision, as much as the substance of the decision itself, influences citizens’ reactions to and acceptance of it. This meticulously constructed study and its persuasively argued conclusion advance the understanding of the media, judicial politics, political institutions, and political behavior.

Get the book

Amazon.com
Amazon.com
Search the book
eBay.com
eBay.com
Search the book

Other editions

Similar books

  • The Limits of Legitimacy: Political Contradictions of Contemporary Capitalism
    The Limits of Legitimacy: Political Contradictions of Contemporary Capitalism
    By Alan Wolfe

    The Limits of Legitimacy: Political Contradictions of Contemporary Capitalism

  • The Limits and Legitimacy of Referendums
    The Limits and Legitimacy of Referendums
    By Richard Albert, Richard Stacey

    These essays - written for scholars, public lawyers, political actors and citizens - bring together diverse perspectives on referendums, constitutionalism, liberalism and democracy in ways that challenge the conventional wisdom, prompt new ...

  • The Limits and Legitimacy of Referendums
    By Richard Albert

    The Limits and Legitimacy of Referendums brings together diverse perspectives on referendums, constitutionalism, liberalism, and democracy in ways that challenge the conventional wisdom, prompt new answers to enduring questions, and urge ...

  • The Limits and Legitimacy of Referendums
    By Richard Albert

    The Limits and Legitimacy of Referendums brings together diverse perspectives on referendums, constitutionalism, liberalism, and democracy in ways that challenge the conventional wisdom, prompt new answers to enduring questions, and urge ...

  • The Rights Paradox: How Group Attitudes Shape US Supreme Court Legitimacy
    The Rights Paradox: How Group Attitudes Shape US Supreme Court Legitimacy
    By Michael A. Zilis

    More recently, however, Bartels and Johnston (2020) argue that these items encapsulate a variety of concepts that include procedural perceptions, trust, and institutional restructuring. Their preferred measurement strategy focuses on ...

  • The Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf: Law and Legitimacy
    The Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf: Law and Legitimacy
    By Øystein Jensen

    The Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf: Law and Legitimacy examines the Commission from two different but interrelated perspectives: a legal analysis of the Commission’s decision-making; and a study of normative legitimacy ...

  • The Limits and Legitimacy of Referendums
    The Limits and Legitimacy of Referendums
    By Richard Albert, Richard Stacey

    Scholars have emphasized a number of tactics that significantly increase autocratic survival, most importantly legitimacy, repression, and cooptation; these are described as the main 'pillars' that support autocratic regimes.1 With the ...

  • Facing the Limits of the Law
    Facing the Limits of the Law
    By Wouter Devroe, Erik Claes, Bert Keirsbilck

    The contributors to this book engage in the challenging task of making sense of this experience.

  • Beyond hegemony: Towards a new philosophy of political legitimacy
    Beyond hegemony: Towards a new philosophy of political legitimacy
    By Darrow Schecter

    The book explains that although many aspects of Marx’s critique are still valid today, his ideas need to be supplemented by the contributions to social theory made by Nietzsche, Foucault, the critical theory of the Frankfurt School as ...

  • On the Limits of Constitutional Adjudication: Deconstructing Balancing and Judicial Activism
    On the Limits of Constitutional Adjudication: Deconstructing Balancing and Judicial Activism
    By Juliano Zaiden Benvindo

    From the critical perception of the serious risks of this movement to democracy, the book takes as examples two constitutional realities, Germany and Brazil, in order to discuss the rationality, correctness, and legitimacy of constitutional ...