The Irony of Free Speech
- ISBN-10
- 0674466608
- ISBN-13
- 9780674466609
- Category
- Political Science / Political Ideologies / Democracy
- Pages
- 98
- Language
- English
- Published
- 1996
- Publisher
- Harvard University Press
- Author
- Owen M. Fiss
Description
How free is the speech of someone who can't be heard? Not very--and this, Owen Fiss suggests, is where the First Amendment comes in. In this book, a marvel of conciseness and eloquence, Fiss reframes the debate over free speech to reflect the First Amendment's role in ensuring public debate that is, in Justice William Brennan's words, truly "uninhibited, robust, and wide-open."
Hate speech, pornography, campaign spending, funding for the arts: the heated, often overheated, struggle over these issues generally pits liberty, as embodied in the First Amendment, against equality, as in the Fourteenth. Fiss presents a democratic view of the First Amendment that transcends this opposition. If equal participation is a precondition of free and open public debate, then the First Amendment encompasses the values of both equality and liberty.
By examining the silencing effects of speech--its power to overwhelm and intimidate the underfunded, underrepresented, or disadvantaged voice--Fiss shows how restrictions on political expenditures, hate speech, and pornography can be defended in terms of the First Amendment, not despite it. Similarly, when the state requires the media to air voices of opposition, or funds art that presents controversial or challenging points of view, it is doing its constitutional part to protect democratic self-rule from the aggregations of private power that threaten it.
Where most liberal accounts cast the state as the enemy of freedom and the First Amendment as a restraint, this one reminds us that the state can also be the friend of freedom, protecting and fostering speech that might otherwise die unheard, depriving our democracy of the full range and richness of its expression.
Get the book
Other editions
Similar books
-
民主的價碼：一人一票，票票「等值」？
By 茱莉亞．卡熱應該說,大多數國家都樣周而反覆。我們要如何擺脫這個惡性循環?我只能再次重申:別怕每年花個幾歐元的 o 於是,政治不平等不斷強化經濟不平等,而經濟不平等又會加深政治不平等,就這所得稅和財富稅,並提高消費稅,將公共支出的重擔轉嫁到社會最弱勢階級的肩上 ...
-
革命時代: 公民抗爭如何改寫21世紀
By 馬克‧恩格勒, 保羅‧恩格勒為什麼有些抗爭被遺忘，有些抗爭卻能引發公共事件，促成改變？他們如何做到？ 公民抗爭若不滿足於「向權力說真相」，而要求確實「造成改變」，什麼樣的策略才是有效的？ ...
-
西方民主鞏固理論研究
By 王菁[5]趙虎吉:《比較政治學:後發展國家視角》,廣州:中山大學出版社,2002年。[6]叢日云:《當代世界的民主化浪潮》,天津:天津人民出版社, 1999年。[7]張小勁:《比較政治學導論(第二版)》,北京:中國人民大學出版社,2008年。
-
The New American Democracy
By Morris P. FiorinaHe pressed for the arrest and trial of Baltimore Ravens football star Ray Lewis for two murders outside a suburban Atlanta bar . But prosecutors could find no evidence linking Lewis to the crime , and Lewis's attorney criticized them ...
-
北京的洋市民：欧美人士与民国北京
By 黄兴涛, 郭双林, 李少兵另一个仆人老王替我洗衣、熨衣、擦鞋,外加照料菜园子,每月才挣十四块中国货币。而且,他还让我签了一纸合同,规定由他提供肥皂、浆水和上蓝剂(防止白衣服变黄的药水),我则负责提供鞋油,另外提供烧开水和热熨斗的煤炭。我的人力包车,连同车夫一起, ...
-
民主政治思辨【自由主义论丛】 第三卷: DISCOURSES ON DEMOCRATIC POLITICS （LIBERAL REVIEW III）
By 荣伟 张千帆 主编《自由主义论丛》在华语世界张扬代表当今 文明世界潮流的自由主义、进步主义理念和价值 观，分析批判逆世界文明进步潮流的极右思潮， ...
-
From Liberty to Democracy: The Transformation of American Government
By Randall G. Holcombe... 280 Schwartz, Anna Jacobson, 307 Schwartzstein, Linda, 302 Secession, 116-17 Securities and Exchange Commission, ... 265, 285 Sobel, Russell S., 283, 287, 293, 302 Socialism as an alternative to liberty, 25 as an economic system, ...
-
The Comedy of Democracy
By Dan D. Nimmo, James E. Combsthrough Election Day , Rogers caricatured the farcical humors of grave campaign politics . ... Oscar G. Brockett , The Theatre : An Introduction ( New York : Holt , Rinehart and Winston , 1964 ) , p . 111 . 2.
-
Democracy: A Beginner's Guide
By David BeethamAs the U.S. strives to establish democracy in Iraq and contemplates its own democratic system in the wake of the presidential election, David Beetham offers new insights into democracy. He...
-
Education for Democracy: Citizenship, Community, Service : a Sourcebook for Students and Teachers
By Richard M. Battistoni, Benjamin R. BarberEducation for Democracy: Citizenship, Community, Service : a Sourcebook for Students and Teachers