In Praise of Nonsense: Kant and Bluebeard

In Praise of Nonsense: Kant and Bluebeard
ISBN-10
0804783063
ISBN-13
9780804783064
Category
Literary Criticism
Pages
272
Language
English
Published
1999-10-01
Publisher
Stanford University Press
Author
Winfried Menninghaus

Description

Shells, leafwork, picture frames, hummingbirds, wallpaper decorations, hems of clothing—such are the examples Kant's Critique of Judgment offers for a "free" and purely aesthetic beauty. Menninghaus's book demonstrates that all these examples refer to a widely unknown debate on the arabesque and that Kant, in displacing it, addresses genuinely "modern" phenomena. The early Romantic poetics and literature of the arabesque follow and radicalize Kant's move. Menninghaus shows parergonality and "nonsense" to be two key features in the spread of the arabesque from architecture and the fine arts to philosophy and finally to literature. On the one hand, comparative readings of the parergon in Enlightenment aesthetics, Kant, and Schlegel reveal the importance of this term for establishing the very notion of a self-reflective work of art. On the other hand, drawing on Kant's posthumous anthropological notebooks, Menninghaus extrapolates an entire Kantian theory of what it means to produce nonsense and why the Critique of Judgment defines genius precisely through the power (as well as the dangers) of doing so. Ludwig Tieck's 1797 rewriting of Charles Perrault's famous Bluebeard tale (1697) explicitly claims to be an "arabesque" book "without any sense and coherence." Menninghaus's close reading of this capricious narrative reveals a specifically Romantic—as opposed, say, to a Victorian or dadaistic—type of nonsense. Benjamin's as well as Propp's, Lévi-Strauss's, and Meletinskij's oppositions of myth and fairy tale lend additional credit to a Romantic poetics that inaugurates "universal poetry" while performing a bizarre trajectory through arabesque ornament, nonsense, parergonality, and the fairy tale.

Get the book

Amazon.com
Amazon.com
Search the book
eBay.com
eBay.com
Search the book

Other editions

Similar books

  • The Nonsense Show
    The Nonsense Show
    By Eric Carle

    A mouse catching a cat? What’s wrong with this book from the creator of The Very Hungry Caterpillar? Yes, there’s something strange, something funny and even downright preposterous on every page of this book.

  • Nonsense: The Power of Not Knowing
    Nonsense: The Power of Not Knowing
    By Jamie Holmes

    What should we do when we have no idea what to do? In Nonsense, Jamie Holmes shows how we react to ambiguous situations and how we can do it better.

  • Fashionable Nonsense: Postmodern Intellectuals' Abuse of Science
    Fashionable Nonsense: Postmodern Intellectuals' Abuse of Science
    By Alan Sokal, Jean Bricmont

    As an example of “confused thinking”, I would like to consider a chapter from Harding (1991) entitled “Why 'Physics' Is a Bad Model for Physics”. I select this example both because of Harding's prestige in certain (but by no means all) ...

  • And Now Let's Move Into a Time of Nonsense: Why Worship Songs are Failing the Church
    And Now Let's Move Into a Time of Nonsense: Why Worship Songs are Failing the Church
    By Nick Page

    Passionate, controversial and laugh-out-loud funny, this is essential reading for Christians today.

  • Faint Praise: The Plight of Book Reviewing in America
    Faint Praise: The Plight of Book Reviewing in America
    By Gail Pool

    Bryant, Eric. “Are Reviewers Fair to Gay and Lesbian Writers?” National Book Critics Circle Journal, Autumn 1999, 4—5. Burgess, Anthony. “Joseph Kell, V. S. Naipaul and Me.” New York Times Book Review, April 21, 1991, 1, 28—31.

  • Perfect Nonsense: The Chaotic Comics and Goofy Games of George Carlson
    Perfect Nonsense: The Chaotic Comics and Goofy Games of George Carlson
    By George Carlson

    ... of Pogo can compare to George Carlson's vast, eclectic legacy of games, gags, and good-spirited amusements. ... systems of meaning involving comics, picture books, nursery rhymes, crossword puzzles, acrostics, rebuses, and the like.

  • A Theology of Nonsense
    A Theology of Nonsense
    By Josephine Gabelman

    ... Neither God nor Master.”16 The apparent incon- sonance derives from the assumption that Christianity is about observing rules and anarchism is about breaking them. The traditional depiction of God as an authoritarian father figure is ...

  • Necessary Nonsense: Aesthetics, History, Neurology, Psychology
    By Irving Massey

    "This book explores the cognitive possibilities of nonsense, literary and philosophical--ranging from Immanuel Kant to Lewis Carol, from examinations of Asperger's Syndrome to the waking state--and demonstrates that there is an element of ...

  • Disgust: Theory and History of a Strong Sensation
    Disgust: Theory and History of a Strong Sensation
    By Winfried Menninghaus

    Bataille, “The Lugubrious Game.” In Visions of Excess, 28. 20. Bataille, CEuvres completes, vol. 1,253. 21. Cf. Didi-Hubermann, La ressemblace informe ou legal savoir visuel selon Georges Bataille. 22. Bataille, “Formless.

  • Common Nonsense: Glenn Beck and the Triumph of Ignorance
    Common Nonsense: Glenn Beck and the Triumph of Ignorance
    By Alexander Zaitchik

    . If you're looking for an antidote to the Beck dreck that Time magazine recently passed off as journalism, this is it."—Kevin Drum, Mother Jones "Despicable, yellow journalism." —Glenn Beck, Fox News Channel Common Nonsense What kind ...