LIBERTY EQUALITY & JUSTICE
- ISBN-10
- 1374723827
- ISBN-13
- 9781374723825
- Category
- Philosophy
- Pages
- 346
- Language
- English
- Published
- 2017-01-27
- Publisher
- Open Dissertation Press
- Authors
- 陳創輝, Chong-Fai Chan
Description
This dissertation, "Liberty, Equality and Justice: a Critique of Kai Nielsen's Radical Egalitarianism" by 陳創輝, Chong-fai, Chan, was obtained from The University of Hong Kong (Pokfulam, Hong Kong) and is being sold pursuant to Creative Commons: Attribution 3.0 Hong Kong License. The content of this dissertation has not been altered in any way. We have altered the formatting in order to facilitate the ease of printing and reading of the dissertation. All rights not granted by the above license are retained by the author. Abstract: Abstract Abstract of thesis entitled Liberty, Equality and Justice: A Critique of Kai Nielsen's Radical Egalitarianism submitted by Chan Chong Fai for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the University of Hong Kong in June 1997. This thesis is a critique of Kai Nielsen's radical egalitarianism--a doctrine which he claims is radically more egalitarian than Rawls' theory of justice, and which spells out Marx's slogan From each according to his ability and to each according to his needs' in a relatively abundant society without classes. The author contends that Nielsen's radical egalitarianism is theoretically inconsistent, practically implausible, and, if it could be implemented, would lead to authoritarianism. Nielsen's theory consists of Rawls' principle of liberty, and Nielsen's principle of economic equality. The latter includes the principle of needs, criteria of desert and entitlement (and maximizing utilities). Nielsen provides a theory with substantial content, but it lacks consistency and practicality. And his egalitarian (of needs) and inegalitarian (of desert, entitlement and utility) elements inevitably clash and dilute the radical nature of his doctrine. Pursuing complete equality of conditions for all is an unrealistic and dangerous pursuit: unrealistic, because it neglects the complexity of our social structure and the diversity of personality and individuals' interests; dangerous, because it may lead to an expansion of the state and diminution of individuals' liberties. The critique is conducted through the perspectives of liberty, equality and justice. The author first contends that Nielsen's conceptions of liberty are a confusion of political ideas and moral goods, and this confusion results in a paradox of liberty. Second, when the abstract and idealistic concept of equality is analyzed into its many (in)equalities and its various dimensions, against the background of the complexity of our society, it is seen to be fraught with inconsistencies and implausibilities. Third, Nielsen's conception of justice as equality is not a coherent whole. Its elements clash with each other and are practically indeterminate. The thesis concludes by looking at the failed experiences of socialism, the possibility of a classless society, and Nielsen's defense of Marx's conception of justice and morality. DOI: 10.5353/th_b2981279 Subjects: Equality Liberty Justice
Get the book
Similar books
-
Ecofeminist Philosophy: A Western Perspective on what it is and why it Matters
By Karen WarrenWijkman and Timberlake , Natural Disasters , 27 . 32. Wijkman and Timberlake , Natural Disasters , 49 . 33. Seager , New State of the Earth Atlas , 121 .
-
Each Day a Renewed Beginning: Meditations for a Peaceful Journey
By Karen Casey7. Sometimes the things that frighten you the most can be the biggest sources of strength. —Iris Timberlake or Most of us learn as we mature that strength.
-
Emerging Trends in Continental Philosophy
By Todd May28 It is therefore not difficult to reconcile Badiou«s references to historical ... On the one hand, Badiou«s major essays on Rancière all deal with the ...
-
Pierre Bayle's Cartesian Metaphysics: Rediscovering Early Modern Philosophy
By Todd RyanBayle offers a similar assessment in a letter to Minutoli: There has just been ... touchant la tran[s]substantiation, et leur conformité avec le calvinisme.
-
Negotiating a Settlement in Northern Ireland, 1969-2019
By John Coakley, Jennifer ToddHowever, acceptance of the deal was driven in part by threats of worse to come should agreement ... see Northern Ireland (St Andrews Agreement) Act 2006, s.
-
The Philosopher's Way
By Pearson Education, Pearson Education Staff, Inc.Several versions of Pearson's MyLab & Mastering products exist for each title, including customized versions for individual schools, and registrations are not transferable.
-
Swimmer in a Dark Sea
By Pierce TimberlakeTake a tour through the mind of America's undiscovered philosopher: Pierce Timberlake. Swimmer in a Dark Sea is a dizzying ride through a dazzling array of profound concepts.
-
Bringing Peace Home: Feminism, Violence, and Nature
By Karen Warren, Duane L. Cady"This collection of works is ambitious, well documented, thoroughly—though not turgidly—referenced, and comprehensively indexed.
-
Ecological Feminism
By Karen Warren, Barbara Wells-HoweThe essays in this volume deal with a wide variety of subjects - the essential distinction between the "ecofeminist" and the "ecofeminine," the link between violence and environmental exploitation, feminism's relationship to animal rights ...
-
Catharine Macaulay's Republican Enlightenment
By Karen Green6 Davies, Catharine Macaulay and Mercy Otis Warren, 228; Franklin Bowditch Dexter (ed.), The Literary Diary of Ezra Stiles (New York: C. Scribner's Sons, ...