Does a language instinct exist? The language Instinct Debate.
- ISBN-10
- 3638396525
- ISBN-13
- 9783638396523
- Category
- Literary Collections
- Pages
- 33
- Language
- English
- Published
- 2005-07-13
- Publisher
- GRIN Verlag
- Author
- Linda Neuhaus
Description
Seminar paper from the year 2005 in the subject English Language and Literature Studies - Linguistics, grade: 1.0, University of Duisburg-Essen (Department of English Linguistics), course: Developments in modern Linguistics, 14 entries in the bibliography, language: English, abstract: In 1994, when Steven Pinker’s book “The language instinct” was published, the linguistic world was confronted with the renewed debate, whether language comes from innate ideas or is just the result of experiencing and learning. This important debate which concerns linguistics until today will be the topic of the following work. The important question is, if a language instinct really exists and which evidence one can provide to assume that our language ability is inherited. Until today, there is great discussion and speculation about innate language ideas and the most important proponent for them nowadays is Steven Pinker. To set his nativist ideas in an appropriate context, it is necessary to explain where the ideas of “nativism” and the opposite linguistic school “empiricism” come from and what characteristics they show. This constructs a context and prepares a base for the focus on Pinker’s book. The most important founder of today’s nativist thoughts is certainly Noam Chomsky, whose ideas were the basis for Pinker’s assumption of a language instinct. For this reason, I will present a short summary of Chomsky’s ideas as the last aspect of the first chapter. Pinker’s arguments put forward in his work “The language instinct” will form the main part and second chapter of my work. I will present his definition of a language instinct and his given evidence for its existence. Because of the complexity of the pieces of evidence put forward in his whole work, I will pick up two of his most important aspects for innate language ideas: Pidgin and creoles and the case of the KE-Family. Afterwards, I will focus on two of his critics, Geoffrey Samspon and Stefan Schaden, because they composed both works being direct responses to Pinker’s “The language instinct”. This will permit us to discuss the question about its existence and which of the arguments for and against it appear more convincing. To prepare this discussion at the end, I will particularly have a closer look at Schaden’s and Sampson’s explicit refutes concerning Pinker’s main points of evidence. As a last step, I will summarize and discuss the arguments of the two sides carefully and complete my work with drawing my personal conclusion about the important question, if a language instinct really exists.
Get the book
Other editions
-
- 2007-09
- 76 pages
- Paperback
- GRIN Verlag
Similar books
-
Educating Eve: The 'language Instinct' Debate
By Geoffrey SampsonAre we creatures who learn new things? Or does human mental development consist of awakening instinctive structures of thought? A view has gained ground that language in much of its...
-
The 'Language Instinct' Debate: Revised Edition
By Geoffrey SampsonChalmers restating dualism: The Conscious Mind: In Search of a Fundamental Theory, Oxford University Press, 1996. ... Bartley, something can come from nothing: 'T he philosophy of Karl Popper, Part Il', Philosophia, 7: 675—716, 1978, ...
-
The Language Instinct: How The Mind Creates Language
By Steven PinkerThis edition includes an update on advances in the science of language since The Language Instinct was first published.
-
The Language Myth
By Vyvyan EvansDrawing on cutting-edge research, Evans presents an alternative to the received wisdom, showing how language and the mind really work.
-
The Stuff of Thought: Language as a Window into Human Nature
By Steven Pinker27 Kasher, 1977; Sampson, 1982. 28 Schelling, 1960, pp. 139—142. 29 Dawkins & Krebs, 1978. 30 Alan Dershowitz, presentation at a seminar On Indirect Speech at the Program for Evolutionary Dynamics, Harvard University, May 16, 2006; ...
-
The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature
By Steven Pinker... 375 Hudson Street, New York, New York 10014, U.S.A. Penguin Group (Canada),90 Eglinton Avenue East, Suite 700, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M4P2Y3 (a division of Pearson Penguin Canada Inc.) Penguin Books Ltd, 80 Strand, London WC2RORL, ...
-
The 'Language Instinct' Debate: Revised Edition
By Geoffrey SampsonWith a new chapter entitled 'How People Really Speak' which uses corpus data to analyse how language is used in spontaneous English conversation, responses to critics, extensive revisions throughout, and a new preface by Paul Postal of New ...
-
The 'Language Instinct' Debate
By Geoffrey SampsonWith a new chapter entitled 'How People Really Speak' which uses corpus data to analyse how language is used in spontaneous English conversation, responses to critics, extensive revisions throughout, and a new preface by Paul Postal of New ...
-
Language: The Cultural Tool
By Daniel L. EverettDrawing on the Wari’ language of Brazil, Everett explains that speakers of all languages, in constructing their stories, omit things that all members of the culture understand.
-
How the Mind Works
By Steven PinkerKlaw, S. 1993. Without sin: The life and death of the Oneida community. New York: Pen— guin. Klein, R. G. 1989. The human career: Human biological and ... Kosslyn, S. M., Pinker, S., Smith, G. E., Schwartz, S. P., 81 commentators. 1979.